Nasih Othman ——- د. ناصح قه‌ره‌داغى

Writings, research and lectures by Dr. Nasih Othman


A memory from the Anfal

A memory from the Anfal genocide of Kurds, 1988

(Draft notes)

The hospital was a small muddy building in a shallow valley that you could not see unless you were either almost there or on the surrounding hilltops. 27th of February 1988 was a clear relatively warm day of the end of winter, we had 5-6 patients lying in the 2 rooms of the hospital.

I was sitting outside in the sun with some colleagues. It was 3:30 pm when we heard the roaring sound of the fighter planes which was so familiar to us and hence so easily recognized!  But the problem with these fighters is that the moment you hear them the next minute they are over your head, so those of us near the bomb shelter quickly jumped in and others run sheltering behind rocks and trees.  I managed to enter the bunker.

We heard the planes coming close and we heard the excruciating sound of the bombs coming towards us but while we were expecting a massive bang, the blast was quite out of proportion. So it was clear for us. Being near the entrance of the shelter I came out t first and I saw a dense white smoke rising near our ambulance. I told my fiends that it was a chemical attack and we had to get away as soon as possible. The plane had apparently located the white shining ambulance and targeted.

But what to do with the patients? We can’t move them! We ran to their rooms while covering our mouth and nose with a handkerchief, and gave them instructions; close the windows, pull the curtain, cover your face with a wet towel and keep the door closed. They all had companions who stayed with the patient.  Then we ran to the hill tops around the hospital and could see that smoke was rising from other places. We could still see the planes circling over the area and bombing other villages. They stayed for 20 minutes and dropped around 40 bombs on and around five villages in addition to the hospital. Later we found 3 other bombs in addition to the one near the ambulance 50-100 meter around the hospital.

When the planes left and the smoke settled, in less than one hour we came back to the hospital and quickly checked the patients, fortunately they were all fine. Two hours after the attack, victims started to come.  In total around 200 people were injured, civilians and militias suffering from burning, redness and watering of the eyes, cough, vomiting, shortness of breath, skin burns and blisters. Most injuries were mild by mountain standards.

The hospital had never been that busy before! Tens of people sitting and lying on the ground rapped in a blanket. We treated them with the simple medications we had. We  also admitted a few victims and one of them died after 2 weeks from respiratory symptoms. He was the first victim of chemical weapons till then in Qaradagh area.

More than 30 goats and a few cows had also died.

So we ended the day and the funny part of the tragedy was uncovered at night. We had a generator line from darkness until 11 o’clock. That night the lamps were exceptionally dim  and while we were sitting for dinner we were trying to find an explanation for that! One of the friends said “maybe the generator is also hit by the chemical gas!” No convincing explanation until 8 o’clock!

One of the team had being serving a patient and meanwhile complaining about the dim lights that night!  The patient was surprised and told him “why dim, they are just like all other nights!” Then he came back to us and told us the story which was not easy to believe, but it was true! None of us had other symptoms, probably we had only a mild congestion in the eye.

But the next morning we got up with some degree of redness and burning of the eyes which only lasted for several hours. Only then we were sure that we were affected by the gases. We were joking about it saying that while we left the patients and ran away from the gases, yet the gases were after us and the patients were safe! Part of this may be true because we were in the open near the gas, but probably we got most of it while attending to the injured after we came back!

We had a heavy rainfall the day after which washed away much of the gases. I checked the bombsite near the ambulance, it was a ditch of  1 meter depth and 3 meter in diameter and I found large peace of shell with letters “LVZ” written on it which probably meant lewisite, one of the blistering gases.

 

****

 


chemical attacks

Eyewitness account of chemical attacks on Kurdish areas during 1987-1988

During 1987-1988 I was working as a medical doctor in the rural areas in Qaradagh area south of Sulaimaniyah, Iraq. I witnessed several chemical attacks on civilians and treated hundreds of patients during this period. I was also mildly injured with blistering gases when the hospital was attacked.  I have also witnessed the Anfal operations of Qaradagh and Garmyan during March and April 1988.

  • 21/4/1987: Fighter plane attacks with blistering gases on several villages Zewamar, Darizyain, Jafaran . Tens of civilians injured
  • 21/4/1988: shelling of Mount Qalaqimaz with blistering gas, one person injured
  • 27/2/1988: Fighter plane attacks with blistering gases on the hospital, and several villages such as Takia, Baklakjar, Gumata, Balkha. Hospital staff and hundreds of civilians and fighters injured, one died
  • 22/3/1988: shelling of Sewsenan and Dukan villages using Nerve gas gas. Over 70 died and hundreds injured
  • 23/3/1988: Shelling of Balakjar with nerve gas. 1 person died
  • 25/3/2016 evacuation of the hospital and relocation to Qopy Mountains.
  • All villagers left their homes towards Sulaimani leaving everything behind. Most of them managed to enter safety but a number of them were taken by regime forces to unkwnon destinations.
  • 30/3/1988 regime enters Qaradagh district and destroys the town
  • 31/3/1988 retreat to Garmyan area.
  • April 1988: Hundreds of villages in Garmyan were now helpless at the middle of regime forces. The villagers were extremely nervous, the area was surrounded by Saddam’s forces from all sides and had no safe place to go. Regime forces started attacking the area from East (Darbandikhan), south (Duz) and west (Chamchamal). The Peshmarga forces resisted for a few days but the attacks were relentless; it was clear the regime had decided to end everything once forever, the resistance as well as the civilian populations. On Aprim 14th, the Peshmerga forces started retreating back to Qopy Mountains and then left the area altogether towards the Iranian border. The civilians has no choice but to surrender to regime forces. They left their villages and moved towards towns controlled by regime forces but vast majority of them never reached there. They were intercepted by the regime forces and taken into unknown destinations.

***

 


Leave a comment

Bad (academic) journals

Be careful when you are invited to submit articles to journals you don’t know!

In a recent workshop in Erbil, Dr Jeffrey Beall gave a lecture about open access publishing and drew our attention to existence of hundreds of online publishers who promote themselves as prestigious academic publishers and invite scholars to submit articles to their journals.  Many of these publishers and their hundreds of online journals (which Beall calls predatory publishers and journals) are in fact only profit-driven and don’t follow academic standards for writing and publishing.. After years of work on this issue, Beall shares his experience and advice through his weblog including a list of publishers http://scholarlyoa.com/publishers/ and a list of standalone journals which http://scholarlyoa.com/individual-journals/

This is a great resource to academic institutions and individual academics. We should avoid publishing in these journals and spread the information to all academic circles in Kurdistan.


Leave a comment

Cherishing our memories

Cherishing our memories
Sometimes on the wings of memories, I travel fast, faster than imagination even, to the bright lanes of my past. The other day I found myself passing in the narrow and tortuous alleys of Homermandan and Sarshaqam that I have not seen for so many years. I wanted to revisit my middle school days when I used to go through this then-shortcut path to Jumhuri school, to Baxi Gishti and Berkhaneqa market. I saw the phantom of my classmates at my sides, heard their voices, paid no attention to the swearing of the bullies on the corners who sometimes used to bully us because we were from the other neighborhood of Qarachawa passing through their jurisdiction! The area had changed a lot and I hardly recognized the location of the bakery where I sometimes used to go and queue for hours to get 10 loaves of hot bread. Although I did not remember where it used to stand, I felt the dignity of the tall tree on which a stark had a nest and used to return every spring to lay eggs and breed a new generation before migrating in autumn to the warmer lands. And there was a Qawurma “sandwich of chickpeas” seller that I can never forget. He had the best qawurma in the area which he used to sell at home just behind the door of his muddy house. Most of the mornings I used to spend my daily pocket money there. On the way to school I used to peek through the door and ask for a qawurma which he made by spreading the ground chick peas on half a loaf of bread and adding some curries and few leaves of leek which I now think were hardly washed at all! It was so delicious that it has given me a permanent like for qawurma. Even now I eat it from time to time at home, albeit never as tasty as that one!

I enjoy traveling back to my memories from time to time and I think it makes my present more pleasant. It is a pity we are so busy with our daily routines that we frequently forget to celebrate our past, not only the wonderful times but all.


Leave a comment

Price of change

In April 2003 in the height of the invasion I was working for a humanitarian agency in Kurdistan. A British colleague, probably having in the back of her mind the involvement of the British troops in the hostilities, wrote to me from London expressing empathy and concern about “the price Iraqi people are paying in the conflict.” But like many Iraqis hopelessly wishing a regime change for decades, I wrote back to her saying “no price was high for ousting the dictator!”

Now when I remember those words, I see how naïve I was then! I had no idea how high the price could be! Indeed, I believe no one thought that things could go this far wrong after the fall of the regime, not even those who planned the invasion! Although as a Kurd I am still happy that the dictator and his army have gone and the threat to Kurdistan has diminished greatly, yet the magnitude of suffering, chaos and destruction during the past four years has being so immense in Iraq that I wouldn’t wish such a regime change  for any country whatever the justifications might be!

March 2007

*****